Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | RSS | More
No Proof Required: How Texas Lets You Register to Vote Without Showing Citizenship
Talking Purple with Beth Guide | November 11, 2026
Today is Veterans Day, so before anything else: to every veteran out there, thank you. We would not be where we are without you. I come from an Air Force family, and I grew up with a deep respect for the military. I hope you all had a great day.
Now I want to ask you a question, and I want you to really think about it before you answer.
What do you have to show to register to vote in Texas?
I’ll save you the trouble. Nothing. Your word is your bond, and that’s it.
I’m not saying I’m right and I’m not saying I’m wrong. But I am saying somebody needs to take a look at this, and I’m going to keep saying it until somebody does.
In Texas, you check a box and go on about your day
Almost everyone agrees you have to be a citizen to vote. I’d bet 85% of you feel that way, regardless of party, because if elections were open to anybody who showed up, you’d change the entire electorate.
So most of us naturally assume somebody is checking. It’s not an unreasonable expectation that you’d have to show some form of ID proving you’re a citizen.
You don’t. When you register in Texas, you check a box and sign an attestation, basically an affidavit, saying “I am a citizen and I’m eligible to vote.” Your application gets processed, and you go on about your day. You’re under threat of perjury if you lie. That’s the safeguard.
Think about that for a second. We already have plenty of people who don’t care much for the law. If they’re handed the opportunity to vote and have a say, and they know nobody is really checking, a lot of them are going to take it.
After you sign, the county clerk or the Secretary of State is supposed to run your application through something that magically spits out whether you’re eligible. Maybe it catches some things. But with labor shortages and overwhelmed systems, I wonder how much of that is actually happening.
And here’s how plugged in the rest of us are: I’m pretty plugged in, and I only found this out two days ago.
I had to prove my citizenship for everything except my vote
This one is personal for me. I’m a naturalized citizen. I was born in Italy.
I’ve had to show my naturalization certificate for my concealed carry permit, which took four months longer than it should have because they wrote back and asked for more. I had to show it for my passport. And when I went to renew my driver’s license during COVID, I couldn’t do it online, because the state didn’t have proof of my citizenship on file. My birth certificate is a reissue from New Jersey, not my Italian original. So I stood in a parking lot for eight hours until somebody let me into the Conroe driver’s license office.
Was I a little hot under the collar that day? Probably. But I treasure my citizenship, so it wasn’t that bad.
But if I had to go through all of that to renew a driver’s license, why didn’t I have to do it to vote?
When I registered at 18 in Wayne, New Jersey, I had to go down to the municipal building with my driver’s license and my naturalization certificate. When I moved to Texas, they asked if I was registered. I said yes, as a Democrat in New Jersey. They said, well, we don’t do that here. And that was that. I asked my sister what she had to do to register, and she said, “You know, Beth, I don’t think I did anything.”
I dare any of you to remember what you had to do. I don’t think anybody knows.
We were all watching the wrong door
After 2020, Republicans reacted. We went after mail-in ballots, dead people and cleaning up the voter rolls. Not to minimize that work. It needed to be done. But nobody thought to check the front door.
The longest-running joke in politics is that if you’re looking for a Democrat voter, go to the cemetery. It goes all the way back to Mayor Daley in Chicago. So everybody went looking in cemeteries. Meanwhile, the real question was sitting right there: who is registering, and is anybody checking whether they’re eligible?
My father and I used to talk about this a lot, and I really learned it during COVID: the law is only as good as its enforcement. So is the Constitution. Yes, you have to be a citizen to vote in Texas. Nobody ever thought to put in a provision that you actually have to show something. I always assumed there were safeguards in the system. It never occurred to me that the system mostly runs on people being honest.
Where did 405,000 new voters come from?
Once I found that out, I went back to the numbers, because numbers are numbers. They can be manipulated, don’t misunderstand me. But numbers don’t lie.
Through 2022, new voter registration in the numbers I was looking at ran about 35,000 to 37,000 people a year. Even in 2020, with COVID and Trump on the ballot, it was only 11,000. The year before that, 38,000. Pretty consistent.
Then it took off:
- 2023: 66,000
- 2024: 150,000
- 2026, an off-year election: 189,000
There’s no historical equivalent to that, at least as far back as I can see. When numbers grow that exponentially, you have to ask where those people came from.
Here’s the part that really got me. There are roughly 405,000 of these new voters, and that exceeds the 383,000 votes the Democrats won by here in Harris County. That alone makes it worth the question.
If you’d asked me on November 2nd, I’d have told you I was looking at the Trump surge, people registering in 2024 to vote against Biden. I never looked past the nose on my face. Well, I have now. I break the year-by-year numbers down in Two Years, Two Different Electorates: What Changed With Harris County’s New Voters.
A 20-point swing in a county that’s always been close
I live in a blue county and a blue city. I accept that. But Harris County has never been far apart. Our county judge races in 2018 and 2022 were within 1%. Take the independents out and the spread was four to six thousand votes. At best, I’d call this a 45% Republican, 55% Democrat county. It is not an 80-20 county.
So when I’m told the results landed in the high 60s and low 70s, swinging all the way from roughly even, that’s a 20-point swing. I want to know the causality. I’m not saying I don’t believe it. I’m saying we need to understand it.
And understand something about Texas “independents.” Texas doesn’t make you declare a party. You’re assigned one based on which primary you vote in, and if you’ve never voted in a primary, you’re labeled an independent. Nobody checked a box that says independent. There’s no such thing as a real independent here.
This year there was an inordinate number of those independent voters, and they made up 40-some percent of the electorate in Harris County. Among the new voters with Hispanic surnames, it looks to me like around 93% went Democrat. You expect me to believe these people were so motivated to vote for Donald Trump in 2024 that they registered, and then swung all the way to the other side two years later? Those two parties are so different now, I’d say apples and oranges, but those are both fruits. It’s more like a water buffalo and a shoe.
The economy doesn’t explain it either. In 2022, inflation was higher and gas was $5. Yes, I’m aggravated that a rib eye costs $39 and it takes 60 or 70 dollars to fill the tank. But overall, 2026 is relatively flat compared to 2022.
And the pattern isn’t the same everywhere. Looking at the 10 biggest counties in Texas, the ones with smaller Hispanic shares, 15% or less, only shifted about 8% toward the Democrats. Honestly, I think a 5% or 6% swing to the Democrats is very plausible. Trump is divisive, and Talarico presents well. Talarico won. I’m not even remotely questioning that. But the counties with large Hispanic shares, around 37%, swung 30%. That’s not exactly right.
I’ve been working with Orlando Sanchez since July of last year, and I think he’s a very honorable person. He outpaced Ken Paxton by 71,000 votes, and Letitia Plummer got 91,000 fewer votes than Talarico, so there was definitely vote splitting. When I take the weird voting patterns out, he actually won by 11,000 votes. I’m not naive enough to think this election is going to be overturned. But this is what it looks like when results get skewed and tipped.
A data analyst sent out an email this week saying there’s no problem with any of this. If you only look at 2026, I can get to where he did. What he missed is 2024. That’s when a large share of these new voters registered, and many of them didn’t show up this year. The ones who did swung 93% blue. That’s not a typical pattern in numbers, and it’s not a typical pattern in people.
Don’t think these things don’t happen
If anybody wants to call me an election denier for asking, I really don’t care. I’d wear that. Common sense has to prevail.
Many years ago I saw Michael Barone on Fox News say there are five counties in America that, if you win them, you win the presidential election: counties like Cuyahoga County in Ohio, Prince George County in Virginia, and Miami-Dade and Broward in Florida. They could feasibly throw an election by throwing enough votes into those counties.
There’s a proven case that changed the presidency: 1960, Nixon and Kennedy. History has a habit of revealing the truth over time, and Chicago manufactured enough votes to throw that election to Kennedy. Mr. Nixon conceded rather than put the country through a scandal. Mr. Trump is not cut from that cloth. He was going to go down fighting, and I’m the same way.
And right here in Harris County, in 2022, the county judge race between Alex Mealer and Lina Hidalgo was very close. On election day, red areas just happened to have no paper to vote on. Polls that were supposed to open at seven didn’t work until 9:30, after all the Republicans had gone to work. There were far more broken machines in red districts than in blue ones.
A criminal court judge lost that year by about 500 votes. The court said there was enough evidence for another election, and the person who “won,” air quotes, kept appealing until the 11th hour, then finally gave up. Tami C. Pierce was seated in 2025. So don’t think these things don’t happen.
We always said trust but verify. These days I’m going to verify everything.
I’m not a “they get what they get” person on immigration
Let me be clear about where I stand, because I even disagreed with some people in my own office about this today.
I came here legally, and if you come here legally, you typically don’t have an ICE problem. I don’t know any legal immigrants who are offended that the law is being enforced. Most of them don’t like illegal immigration any more than I do.
But something has to be done about the people who have been here 20 years or more, maybe even 15. Most Americans think there’s a path to citizenship. There isn’t. That’s exactly why we keep hearing about the need for one. Now the visa office is so backed up that people come here on a 90-day visa and become illegal just because they can’t get it renewed.
I’m going to be 60 in a couple of days. If somebody tried to send me back to Italy now, I know how to say spaghetti and pizza. Maybe spaghetti with meat sauce. Picking up a kid who played Nintendo on his sofa for half his life and dropping him in Colombia is not going to end well. And yes, I say DACA “kids,” and I know some of them are 40. You don’t take people that Americanized, who may not even speak the language, and dump them in Ecuador or El Salvador or Guatemala.
If people understood how government works, instead of making TikTok videos and throwing themselves in front of cars, they’d be telling their congressman to create a program that gives these people some kind of legal status.
And this is exactly why voter eligibility matters. If the people voting were eligible, I don’t think ICE explains a 93% swing. If they weren’t, then I understand why they’d vote that way. They don’t want ICE knocking on their door.
What I’m asking for
Before this election is certified, I want our elected officials to run these new voters through a database and answer some simple questions:
- Are they eligible? Run a citizenship check on the 2024, 2025 and 2026 new registrations. Run it on all of us, what the heck.
- Who registered them, and are there patterns?
- Where were they registered before, and did they come through Harris County or relocate here?
- When did they register, if this is the first time they voted?
- Are there specific addresses that keep showing up?
If every one of them comes back eligible, great. People get peace of mind. If they don’t, you fix it. I lay these checks out in more detail in Who Registered Them? Five Checks Texas Should Run Before the Election Is Certified.
I’d add one more. When I used Claude to help crunch these numbers, it suggested the Attorney General and the State of Texas should also ask how many short ballots were filed. A short ballot is for people who’ve moved. It only covers the top of the ballot, the state races, not local county issues. Several people told me they were asked to fill one out this year after never having done it before. That data report didn’t look at that either.
And the governor, who left this door open, needs to call a special session and close it. You cannot leave it so that anyone can come to Texas, register, say they’re a citizen, and nobody checks.
Some people say the Department of Justice would have caught this, or Donald Trump would have known. If you don’t think to think about it, you don’t think of it. Who would ever assume nobody is checking? Google it, ChatGPT it, put it in Claude. You’ll find out I’m right. So you can all take your voter integrity nonsense about dead people. I’m worried about live people who can come here, not show they’re citizens and still participate in our elections.
And think about where people come into this country: Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, California, and Texas has the biggest border. Get registered here, and when an ICE agent stops you, you hand over your voter card. “Here’s my voter card, Mr. ICE man, I don’t know why you’re bothering me.” A voter registration card implies you’re a citizen, whether that’s right or not.
This should bother you no matter who you voted for
If we let this continue, now that it’s understood you don’t have to prove citizenship to register in Texas, we will never get back to a free and fair election system. It will always be a thumb on the scale. It lets people without eligibility or skin in the game decide where your tax dollars go.
Whether you hate Donald Trump or like him, that’s bad for everybody. Because Republicans could just as easily wake up and say, well, if you’re doing it, I’m going to do it too. That’s not right either.
I do not believe in cheating, in either direction. If my ideas are better, vote for me. If you think the other guy’s are better, vote for him. That’s where I draw the line. More on this in Something Doesn’t Add Up in Texas: Verify Voter Eligibility Before 2026 Is Certified.
A few more things on my mind
Why I started Talking Purple. I started this podcast over a year ago because social media algorithms don’t give ample voice to the other side. Whatever side you sit on, you never see the other one, so you’re only deciding based on what you’re shown. I actually like Van Jones. He’s really smart. He was on CNN explaining how a PAC reached tens of thousands of people to convince them the economy was terrible, and manipulated the algorithms to get a response. You could be doing okay, but if you’re told your neighbor is struggling, you think it’s a bad economy. It all comes down to one word: manipulation. (And my sister keeps sending me annoying videos, so now that’s all TikTok shows me. I need a separate account just for her.)
The economy. Until steak and gas prices come down, I’m not thrilled with this economy, from a business standpoint or a supermarket standpoint. More small businesses shutter every week. I want businesses to be able to thrive, because that’s what creates opportunity for everybody. Honestly, I don’t think we’ve had a good economy since 2019.
Elizabeth Warren and the minimum wage. She says Democrats will raise the minimum wage and make Donald Trump veto it. If you think raising the minimum wage lowers costs, you need an arithmetic lesson. Every business passes that cost back to the consumer. The minimum wage was never meant to be a living wage, and nobody should aspire to it. Raise it, prices go up, then you want to raise it again. Where do you stop, $153,000 an hour? It’s not a money in problem. It’s a money out problem. Lowering costs is where the rub is.
AI. When people call and ask what I’m doing, I tell them I’m taking over the world. If you understand how to use AI, you have a leg up on everyone else.
If it walks like a duck
There’s a whole bunch of things here that got left off the table so you can have the narrative that there’s nothing wrong. Maybe all these new voters just woke up and decided they don’t like Republicans anymore. Then what does it hurt to go look?
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck and looks like a duck, it’s not a platypus.
This is Beth Guide with Talking Purple, and I will be back soon.
Watch the full episode above or on the Talking Purple YouTube channel, and find every past episode on the Talking Purple blog.
More from Talking Purple
- Who Registered Them? Five Checks Texas Should Run Before the Election Is Certified
- Two Years, Two Different Electorates: What Changed With Harris County’s New Voters
- Something Doesn’t Add Up in Texas: Verify Voter Eligibility Before 2026 Is Certified
- The Morning After: Why Harris County Went Straight Blue and What Republicans Got Wrong
- Harris County Early Voting 2026 Wrap-Up: All 12 Games, Every Race, Before Election Day
